கிராமப்புற மாணவர்களுக்கு எதிரானதா #நீட் தேர்வு ?

13 Sep

கடந்த சில நாட்களாக தமிழகத்தை உலுக்கி கொண்டு இருப்பது #நீட் தேர்வு விவகாரம். நீட் தேர்விற்கு எதிராக நிறைய குற்றச்சாட்டுகள் – அதில் பிரதானமான ஒன்று ” #நீட் தேர்வு சமூக நீதிக்கு எதிரானது ” மற்றும் ” #நீட் தேர்வு கிராமப்புற மாணவர்களுக்கு எதிரானது ” . 

#நீட் தேர்வு வருவதற்கு முன் நம் தமிழக கிராமப்புற மாணவர்கள் நிலை எவ்வாறாக இருந்தது ? எத்துணை கிராமப்புற மாணவர்கள் கடந்த ஆண்டுகளில் மருத்துவ படிப்பில் சேர்ந்தார்கள் என்ற உண்மையான புள்ளி விவரம் யாரிடத்திலும் இருப்பதாக தெரியவில்லை.

தமிழகத்தில் பத்து ஆண்டுகளுக்கு முன்பு வரை மருத்துவ மற்றும் பொறியியல் பட்ட படிப்பிற்கான நுழைவு தேர்வு ஒன்று இருந்ததயே யாரும் சொல்வதில்லை. 2006 அம் ஆண்டு வரை  TNPCEE  – Tamil Nadu Professional Courses Entrance Examination  இருந்து வந்தது .

அதை 2006இல் ரத்து செய்யப்பட்டபோதும் சொல்லபட்ட காரணம் – கிராமபுற மாணவர்களால் சிறப்பு பயிற்சிக்கு செலவு செய்ய இயலாது – நுழைவு தேர்வு ரத்து செயதால் கிராமப்புற மாணவர்கள் பயன்பெறுவார்கள் – உண்மையில்நடந்தது என்ன ?

தகவல் அறியும் சட்டத்தின் கீழ் வெளியிடப்பட்ட ஒரு புள்ளி விவரப்படி 2006 முதல் 2016 வரை  பதினோரு  ஆண்டுகளில் 2%  சதவிகிதற்கும் குறைவான அரசு பள்ளியில் தேர்ச்சி பெற்ற மாணவர்கள் மருத்துவ படிப்பில் சேர்ந்துஉள்ளனர் .

2006 முதல் 2016 வரை  பதினோரு ஆண்டுகளில் மொத்தம் உள்ள 29925 அரசு மருத்துவ கல்லுரி இடங்களில் அரசு பள்ளியில் படித்த மாணவர்கள் 213 சேர்ந்துள்ளனர் – அதாவது சாசரியாக ஒரு ஆண்டிற்கு 19.8 ( 213 /11 ) மாணவர்கள் மட்டுமே சேர்ந்தனர் .

2006 முதல் 2016 வரை  பதினோரு ஆண்டுகளில் மொத்தம் உள்ள  6132 சுய நிதி மருத்துவ கல்லூரிகளில் அரசுக்கு ஒதுக்கப்பட்ட இடங்களில்  அரசு பள்ளியில் படித்த 65 மாணவர்கள் சேர்ந்துள்ளனர் – அதாவது சாசரியாக ஒரு ஆண்டிற்கு 5.9 ( 65 /11 ) மாணவர்கள் மட்டுமே சேர்ந்தனர் .

இது நீட்டிற்கு முந்திய கதை.

 

இந்த ஆண்டு #நீட் தேர்வின் அடிப்படியில் நிரப்பபட்ட இடங்கள் விவரம் பல உண்மைகளை வெளிச்சத்திற்கு கொண்டு வந்துள்ளது .

Suj-medical-admGNL2E878C1jpgjpg

 

திண்டுக்கல் ,திருவண்ணாமலை , ராமநாதபுரம் போன்ற பின் தங்கிய மாவட்டங்களில் இருந்து கணிசமான மாணவர்கள் மருத்துவ இடங்களை பிடித்துள்ளனர்.

dindigul.JPG

 

சமீபத்தில் தற்கொலை செய்துகொண்ட அனிதாவின் சொந்த அரியலூர் மாவட்டத்தில் கடந்த ஆண்டைவிட  நீட் தேர்வுக்கு பிறகு 17 மாணவர்கள் கூடுதலாக  மருத்தவ படிப்பில் சேர்ந்துள்ளார்கள்.

 

ariyalur.JPG

இந்த நீட் தேர்வை கடுமையாக எதிர்க்கும் தீமுக கட்சி தலைவர் தொகுதியான திருவாரூரில் கடந்த ஆண்டு 2 மாணவர்கள்  மட்டுமே மருத்துவ படிப்பில் சேர்ந்தனர் இந்த வருடம் 28 அதாவது 26 மாணவர்கள் கூடுதலாக சேர்த்துள்ளனர் . அதை ஒட்டிய நாகை மாவட்டத்தில் கடந்த கடந்த ஆண்டுடன் ஒப்பிடுகையில் 18 மாணவர்கள் கூடுதலாக சேர்த்துள்ளனர் .
tiruvarur

திமுக என்றுமே கிராமப்புற மாணவர்கள் வளர்ச்சியில் அக்கறை காட்டியதே இல்லை என்பதற்கு இதை விட பெரிய சான்று தேவையா ?

2006 இல் நுயைவு தேர்வு ரத்தானது யாருக்கு சாதகம் ஆனது ?  ஈரோடு நாமக்கல் சுற்றுவட்டாரத்தில்  தனியார் உறைவிட பள்ளிகள் புற்றீசல் போல் பெருகி வந்தன – ஒரு ஆண்டின் பீஸ் லட்சம் ரூபாய் – இவர்கள் சாதனை ? +11 ஆரம்பம் முதலே இருண்டு வருடம் 12அம் வகுப்பு பாடத்தயே மனப்பாடம் செய்ய வைத்து  200/200 வாங்க வைப்பது மட்டுமே குறிக்கோள் – அதன் விளைவே வருடா வருடம் இவர்கள் மாநிலத்திலே எப்போதும் முதல் இடம் பிடிப்பது.

erode.JPG

#நீட் வந்ததும் எல்லாம் தலை கீழ் ஆனது – இந்த வருடம் நாமக்கல் மாவட்டத்திலிருந்து 109 மாணவர்கள் மட்டுமே மருத்துவத்தில் சேர்ந்துள்ளனர் – கடந்த ஆண்டைவிட 848 குறைவு – நீட் இவர்களின் தரத்தை கேவலமாக அம்பலப்படுத்தி இருக்கு . ஒரே ஒரு மாணவனை வெய்து சில  லட்சம் வாங்கும் தனியார் பள்ளிகள் லாபி தாங்குமா இந்த நஷ்டத்தியும் அசிங்கத்தையும் ?

இந்த ஆண்டு #நீட் வந்த பிறகு அரசு மருத்துவ கல்லுரி இடங்களில் அரசு பள்ளியில் படித்த மாணவர்கள் 2 மாணவர்கள் மட்டுமே சேர்ந்துள்ளனர் , என்ற செய்தி வெளியாகியுள்ளது .

இந்த ஆண்டு #நீட் வந்த பிறகு சுய நிதி மருத்துவ கல்லூரிகளில் அரசுக்கு ஒதுக்கப்பட்ட இடங்களில் அரசு பள்ளியில் படித்த மாணவர்கள் 3 மட்டுமே சேர்ந்துள்ளனர் , என்ற செய்தி வெளியாகியுள்ளது .

இந்த செய்தி உண்மையாகவே இருக்கும் பட்சத்தில் இதில் ஆச்சர்யம் ஏதும் இல்லை ஏனென்றால் எல்லா அரசியல்வாதிகளும் தங்கள் சுயநலத்திற்காகவும் விளம்பரத்திற்காவும் கிராமப்புற மாணவர்களின் மேல் அக்கறை இருப்பது போல் நீலி கண்ணீர் வடிக்கீறார்கள் .

கடந்த 10 ஆண்டுகளில் எத்தனை கிராமப்புற , அரசு பள்ளியில் பயின்ற மாணவர்கள்  IAS / IPS மற்றும் IIT தேர்வுகளில் தேர்ச்சி பெற்றார்கள் என்ற உண்மையை நீட் எதிர்ப்பாளர்கள் சொல்வார்களா ?

கிராமப்புற மாணவர்கள் மேல் உண்மையான அக்கறை இருக்கும் எவராக இருந்தாலும் நீட்டிற்கு மட்டும் இல்லாமல் மற்ற நுழைவு தேர்வுகளுக்கு சேர்த்து இலவச சிறப்பு பயிற்சி கேட்டு போராட வேண்டும்.

கிராமப்புற மாணவர்கள் எதிர்காலம் நீட் தேர்வை ரத்து செய்வதால் வர போவதில்லை – அவர்களுக்கு இலவசமான தரமான எல்லா நுழைவு தேர்வுகளுக்கான பயிற்ச்சி மட்டுமே குடுக்கு முடியும் . அதற்கு தான் அவர்கள் மேல் உண்மையான அக்கறை இருப்பவர்கள் போராட வேண்டிய ஒன்று.

நீட் எதிர்ப்பாளர்கள் எவருமே ஒரு நாகரீமான விவாதத்திற்கு யாரும் தயாரில்லை .

இதை எதிர்க்கும் ஸ்டாலின் அவர்களுக்கு தற்கொலை செயது கொண்டது அனிதாவா சரிதாவா என்ற குழப்பம் தீர்ந்ததா இல்லையா தெரிய்வில்லை .

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

sacrilege of Hinduism in the name of anti #NEET protests

12 Sep

My Earlier Blogs on #NEET – 

#NEET controversy is repeated exemption to TN a solution ?

The great #NEET loot by other state students in TN ?

Is #NEET against #SocialJustice ?

Are rural students affected by #NEET in TN ?

The recent series of protests against #NEET is snowballing into a Sacrilege of Hinduism by vested interests .

Cant understand the logic what way #NEET is remotely associated with Hinduism ?

#NEET has been projected as anti social justice but now the lie has been exposed very badly after seeing that it is no way true.

The Tamil cinema industry is in the forefront of sacrilege of Hinduism in TN –

In a condolence meeting organised for unfortunate suicide of Anita – Pa.Ranjith  who is director of superstar Rajinikanth earlier film ” Kabaali ” and yet to be released ”Kaala ” talks ill of Hinduism – he says – ” it is important what philosophy we follow , Hinduism has ruined , severely murdered , without even allowing us to think ( raises voice ) has ensured there is nothing left behind in our head , we have to think , only from that thoughts we will give path to protests and revolution and that alone will give us success  ” .

He goes on to say – ” Why our our streets are restricted to surrounding temples ? Why the people who are in front of temple are like this and those who are in back of temple like this ? who is owning the temple lands ? We dont ask any such questions and our life will be over without asking these . Religion is playing a serious role in our lives . If you just put a grass and say it was done by lord Ram we will believe it was done by him because we are tuned to be that way  ” .

 

Another Director Karu Palaniappan makes fun of celebrating Krishna Jayanthi – he doesnt name but a obvious reference to UP CM – ”happens in which country ? 100 children die and CM asks go and celebrate krishna jayanthi ‘

 

He makes a reference to Bagavath Geetha addresses PM and says – ” you have grown by reading Bagavath Geetha , please dont read Bagavath Geetha – it justified killing of Karna by hiding – it will only do this so dont read Bagavath Geetha as you will also do the same  ” 

Youtube is full of such hatred speeches on Hinduism on #NEET –

Cant understand the logic by these people attempting sacrilege of Hinduism in the name of anti  #NEET protests and also a students union has attempted to climb temple RajaGopuram ( main tower ) of Sri Andal Temple , Sri Villiputtur – it also happens to be official state symbol of Tamilnadu government

 

Cant understand what way #NEET is remotely connected to Hinduism ? has any protester climbed temple tower in rest of india except TN and this incident has been blacked out by tamil media – just cant imagine the noise level if any minority place of worship was there instead of this temple .

None of these people understand that Sacrilege of Hinduism in the name of anti #NEET protests cannot do any damage to the religion as it is a most inclusive ,evolving , tolerant progressive and truly secular religion of the world .

 

Is regulating online harassment job of a Union WCD minister #Part2

11 Sep

Last year WCD Smt.Maneka Gandhi had introduced a hashtag #ImTrolledHelp to help (?) women being harassed online.

Subsequently i blogged on this subject –

Is regulating online harassment job of WCD union minister ? 

I had filed RTI Request Registration number MOWCD/R/2016/50475 dated 17.8.2016 – my query was –

Since announcement of the special cell for dealing of online stalking and abuse of women I wish to know totally how many complaints have been received as on date and I wish to know the breakup of the locations from where complaints received and breakup of the medium from which it was received like how much was from face book , how much from twitter and if any other online source .Also would like to know how much of these cases have been fit for further ac_on . Also please let me know the actions taken on the cases you found fit for further pursuance ”. 

rti 1

Till date i did not recieve any reply even after one year . When i check the status it says ”request forwarded to CPIO on 18.8.2016 ” .

It simply means there is no records maintained on the total number of cases booked and this is just a PR exercise .

 

list.JPG

I had filed another RTI –  RTI Request Registration number MOWCD/R/2016/50567 dated 23.9.2016 – my query was –

” Please provide the agreement copies or appointment order issued to 2 Social media consultants engaged by your ministry for handling Social media related issues ” 

status as on date ( 11.9.17 ) for the above RTI says ” request forwarded to CPIO on 26.9.2016 ” .

rti 2.JPG

There is no reply to the above RTI till date even after one year .

So i filed a fresh RTI – RTI Request Registration number MOWCD/R/2017/50425 dated 10.8.2017 – my query was  –

” please provide agreement copies of two consultants engaged for handling of social media accounts of your ministry ” .

rti 3.JPG

 

Surprisingly i got a reply for my above RTI –

rti reply 1

rti reply 2

It says there is only appointment letters issued – the names /address have been masked .

I fail to understand what is the need to mask the identity of the persons engaged when it is tax payers money which is being put to use ? who is being shielded ? 

Will revealing the identity of the engaged person pose a threat to them ? Or is it a grave national secret which will jeopardize national security ?

Funny are the way our bureaucrats function – even after one year they are yet to reply how many cases have been booked under their campaign to help curb online abuse of women and children .

In 1st place i do not understand the existence of a separate cabinet post for a ministry like WCD which in real terms in my opinion doesnt deserve a full time minister at all and the way public money is being wasted on things the ministry has no control is unworthy .

Even after one year introduction of one year of her #ImtrolledHelp which got converted to #HelpMeWCD i dont see any reduction of any cases of trolling coming on its own – even after action taken in @Dhanyarajendran  case nobody have learnt any lesson – latest is the voluminous abuses Dr.Tamilisai is facing for her pro #NEET stand –

 

The kind of words / abuses hurled at her are totally ignored by entire media fraternity and will be interesting to watch if WCD ministry step in this ?

WCD cannot regulate such online abuses and its better it doesnt waste time on this – probably the only segment which is enthused by #HelpMeWCD are the female journalists who are part of her alleged whatsapp group and yet to see its utility for public .

 

Are rural students affected by #NEET in TN ?

10 Sep

This is 4th in the series of my blogs on #NEET – my earlier blogs –

#NEET controversy is repeated exemption to TN a solution ?

The great #NEET loot by other state students in TN ?

Is #NEET against #SocialJustice ?

 

Leader after leader , every politician except BJP leaders from TN and Dr.Krishnaswamy of PuthiaTamilagam and his son Dr.Shyam  have been opposing #NEET and the reasons they quote is that it is against ”Rural students ” .

TN ministers met central union ministers and repeatedly were parroting ” rural students will be affected due to #NEET and need exemption for TN ” . Union minister  Mrs. Nirmala sitharaman said she saw the data given by TN ministers which showed rural students will be affected .

When the #NEET case up in SC it asked them to come up with a solution that not a single student is affected by the ordinance of one year exemption at the same time submit the lists rural students and merit lists based on their usual system and #NEET. When the ordinance was pronounced after the AG did a U turn on ordinance no news reports to confirm if the lists were submitted and also till date no such data released – which increases the mystery .

It is highly doubtful if any such classification of data exists of previous years rural students getting medical seats to show it has gone down due to #NEET.

But the facts in public domain are shocking – as per  RTI –

Not even 2 percent of Tamil Nadu government school kids study medicine

only 0.7 per cent of MBBS students in government medical colleges and 1.1 percent in private colleges come from government schools across the State. Government school students could secure only 213 of the 29,925 seats in government medical colleges. It is even less in the case of private colleges, where only 65 of the whopping 6,132 seats were grabbed by students from State-run schools, said The Tamil Nadu Dr MGR Medical University, in response to an RTI application. The data is for the period between 2006 and 2016.

Till 2006 there was

Tamil Nadu Professional Courses Entrance Examination (TNPCEE)

which was an entrance examination used for admitting students to the Engineering and Medical Colleges and was abolished in 2006 and the reason cited for scrapping was that reason is to ”  create a level playing field for the rural students. The Government claimed that urban students have an edge in the Entrance Examination ” .

So has anything changed on ground  between 2006 – 2016 ? The real poor students are repeatedly used as a political tool by parties / govt to justify their decisions – if scrapping of TNPCEE was done to enable rural students get entry to medicine then why from 2006 -2016 the situation is pathetic ?

TN govt is answerable to the public on steps it has taken in last 10 years to improve rural students condition and if any steps taken why no visible results ? Who will take the blame ? The politicians or bureaucrats ?

Answer lies in the fact that everybody has failed rural students – Mr.H,Raja had clearly pointed out that #NEET will in fact help  rural students as now they will be taught 11th std portions once they enter 11th std instead of teaching 12th std portion for 2 years as is being done now .

The biggest beneficiary of the scrapping of TNPCEE is handful of private schools from Namakkal who have been getting lions share of medical admissions and due to #NEET they stand exposed very badly .

Suj-medical-admGNL2E878C1jpgjpg.jpg

Source of the above  graphics –  “NEET has blown the myth that students from SC, ST will lose out ”. 

Take specific cases of really backward districts of Tamilnadu –

dindigul.JPG

 

Are these not ”rural areas ” ? if #NEET was hindrance to rural students how did they perform ?

Take the case of Ariyalur which is also a backward district and is native of Anita who unfortunately committed suicide the gain is huge –

ariyalur

The most insulting figure is that of Tiruvarur which happens to be MLA constituency of Mr.karunanidi – 

tiruvarur

I term the above figure insulting as DMK is spearheading anti #NEET agitation saying #NEET affects rural students – last year just 2 candidates got seat means they have done nothing for rural students whereas this year 28 – means they have no link to ground level realities .

The Namakkal Lobby is the biggest loser in #NEET – just handful of schools have been year after year repeating performance of highest number of students scoring 200/200 in all subjects directly resulting highest number of medical seats –

namakkal.JPG

It clearly establishes that the abolishing of #NEET in TN will help only memorizing factories of Namakkal and private schools .

in 2017 – Tamilnadu state Board students performance –

187 students scored 200/200 physics, 1123 centums were seen in chemistry and Biology had 221 students . 

2010- 2016 –

12th.JPG

The above info given to me by @vnktabi 

A further split up will show up that memorising factories of Namakkal will be a major contributor for the centums .

Tamilnadu govt has announced 450 free #NEET coaching centers  which is a welcome move and i wish majority of this comes up in rural areas to benefit rural students and alternately union HRD ministry can also step in to set up much centers in TN.

Instead of fooling public in the name of #NEET affecting rural students i wish TN politicians should demand ( which i personally feel will never happen )  more free #NEET coaching centers and TN BJP leaders can take help of union HRD ministry .

 

 

 

 

Is #NEET against #SocialJustice ?

10 Sep

Please view my earlier 2 blogs on #NEET –

#NEET controversy is repeated exemption to TN a solution ?

The great #NEET loot by other state students in TN ?

Nowadays once you switch on to any Tamil TV news channel one common dialogue you will find people screaming that #NEET is against social Justice .

For many many years Secularism has been the most misused misinterpreted word in TN politics and now post unfortunate Anita Suicide it is ”Social Justice ” .

Social justice is a term which has been interpreted by TN politicians to suit their political stand which changes time to time and by a section of them to spit venom against forward castes specifically brahmins and in this specific case of #NEET as if entire seats is going to be taken away by them .

Also majority of Tamil cine industry stars / directors have stepped in and used this as opportunity to defame pm Shri. Narendramodi and Pa.Ranjith – director of Superstar Rajinikanth`s last film ”Kabali ” and yet to be released ” kaalaa ” went to extent of defaming Hinduism in worst possible way and many others additionally used it to demand for a separate ”nation” Seceding from india .

 

 

One of the directors – Karu Palaniappan went to the extent to dragging UP CM Shri.Yogi Adityanath in this #NEET issue – which is totally absurd

He goes on to even drag sacred Bagavath Geetha in social justice cry on #NEET – sounds very weird .

lets come to facts – Tn has the highest reservation of seats / jobs – total 69% and only 31% left for OC – Open competition which is free for all  .reservation

The policy which is followed by TN is that they 1st start with OC in which they allot seats to BC/MBC/SC/ST candidates – during medical admission they take a undertaking from them that they are foregoing their reservation status for that counselling – and after that come for BC/BC /BCM ( muslims ) /SC/SC ( Arunthatiyar ) /ST .

A state like Odisa which has one of the highest Tribal population in india follows the reservation policy which is totally contrast to what is done in TN –GUIDELINES FOR COUNSELLING &ADMISSION TO MBBS/BDS COURSES – 2017-18 -ODISSA

This is the guideline for #NEET in Odissa – it clearly states – ” The order of counseling in spot round of counseling shall be
Scheduled Tribe (ST) – Scheduled Caste (SC) – Physically Challenged
(PC) – Ex Servicemen (ES) – Green Card (GC) – General (GEN). ” does it mean Odissa govt is against social justice ?

neet odisa

A major blame for the flaring up of this false propaganda of #NEET against social justice lies with visual media – especially  channels like  News18Tamilnadu – they have been the worst in spreading lies  –

news18.JPG

once This figure came immediately social media was filled with hate towards pm that he was trying to impose ”kula kalvi murai ” ( Hereditary Education Policy ),  he brought #NEET to bring brahmins by backdoor  and this slide picked up like a wild fire in whatsapp groups too and im sure must have been the same in FB too .

Cant conclude on what basis this slide was made .

This is the  date wise,  category wise allocation to medical colleges from 24.8.17 – 28.8.17 for the 1st 2500 govt medical college seats and it  no way matches what was projected by News18Tamilnadu

2500

This is the actual figures of seats finally allotted – govt medical college and private medical college ( govt quota ) seats –

All segments of reserved category benefited –

As can be seen from above figures all segments who enjoy reservation in TN have benefited big way in spite of #NEET and in spite of this vested interests have been spreading lies that #NEET is against Social Justice .

% benefit

In final analysis it is beyond doubt that #NEET in TN has no way snatched away the reservation benefits of any community on the contrary every segment is benefitted – instead of telling these facts every tamil channel still telecasts political party members and now even school students screaming #NEET is against Social Justice .

All the above data extracted from http://www.tnhealth.org/ by downloading date wise allocation of seats .

 

 

 

The great #NEET loot by other state students in TN ?

9 Sep

My earlier Blog on #NEET –

#NEET controversy is repeated exemption to TN a solution ?

There has been a huge campaign at multiple levels against #NEET in Tamilnadu and ever since unfortunate suicide of Anitha – a picture is created in rest of india as if entire Tamilnadu is fighting against it .

While this goes on ,  feeble voices of affected students / parents who are complaining against seats of TN being taken up by  students of neighboring state of Kerala is going unheard and not a single politician opens their mouth and also not a single tamil cine stars / directors opening their mouth on it .

The Supreme Court has already given judgment in the year 2016, that a candidate from Madhya Pradesh domicile category will be given first preference and only if the seats were vacant after the list of state domicile candidates was exhausted then in that circumstance non-domicile category candidates can be considered.

The court order is crystal clear that the one candidate could not be a domicile of two states in the country.

There was big controversy recently in MP and Supreme court intervened and ordered cancellation of admissions to medical colleges, fresh counselling from August 31, 2017 .

This cancellation happened due to 34 proven cases of domicile fraud –

NEET 2017: MP govt cancels admissions to medical colleges, counselling from August 31

“We will follow the court orders. The directorate of medical education found 34 students, who had mentioned the name of other states in the NEET form, and took admission in the state quota seats in MP,” DME joint director Shashi Gandhi said.

I have been putting a series of tweets on this #NEET in my twitter handle ( @rangats ) giving screenshots of list of candidates whose name appear in merit list of both TN and Kerala – which is a clear violation of supreme court order .

Here it is –

Total number of candidates whose name i have – 42 from other states whose name are in merit list of TN and Kerala for 2017-2018 .

Initially i had put up 35 names based on what was given to me by a twitter handle @TN_MBBS later on 7 other names given to me by @respon2016

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Any student is eligible to apply for state quota seats with domicile and as per supreme court one student can apply only one state – to make things clear if any state for example has 1000 seats 850 seats ( 85% )  will go to the state merit list and balance 150 seats go to all india quota .

Students are free to apply for management quota outside the state anywhere in india .

Students are free to apply for all india quota and allows them advantage of getting seats anywhere in india .

In addition to this there is deemed university quota and students are free to apply for it anywhere in india .

All students are very much aware of domicile law and in spite of this seems these students have deliberately applied in TN – for Kerala students #NEET confusion has come as god sent and since the ranking is like 1: 10  if a student is 27 state rank in TN it is 596 in kerala – since competition is heavy in kerala due to very high performance .

If these students are genuinely domicile of TN then why did they apply for Kerala merit list ? Clearly this is a serious offence of applying in 2 states merit list quota – till now no visible action is seen – saw some news item that against 7 students action initiated – no names revealed – also that undertaking taken from candidates whose domicile is suspicious – will just a undertaking suffice ?

Tamilnadu has one of  the highest number of medical seats in india and it is highly unfair and injustice to TN students that their seats are snatched by students of other states and specifically Kerala – its surprising to note that there are no allegations of students from AP/Telangana/Karnataka involved in such what i would allege to be a malpractice and this is nothing short of a loot .

Also a close look would reveal majority of the names from a particular  community and if is it part of a grand plan by communist forces to plant their ideology in education sector in TN  ? only time will .

In spite of me and many others raising this not a single politician especially those who earn their bread and butter and survival is based on their so called fight for ”Tamils” are totally deaf dumb and blind to these facts .

It needs a thorough investigation as to how many of these students submitted fake nativity certificates and how many of them used the loophole of laws – if it is former criminal action to be initiated and if it is the case of former , TN needs to alter rules if not done ( there is lack of clarity to me as not able to find a clear guideline on this online ) in such a way that TN medical seats should go to only TN domicile students – when i say TN domicile students it means anybody who has studied in TN from 8th std to 12th std – as TN govt has invested heavily on healthcare and others should not be allowed to exploit this loophole .

If at all there is a loophole in TN who is behind exposing this loophole to kerala students when no such allegation from AP/Telangana/karnataka students is found ? Which is the lobby behind this ? Need to be exposed and the loophole plugged .

Continue reading

#NEET controversy is repeated exemption to TN a solution ?

26 Jul

There has been a huge hue and cry in TN calling for ”exemption” to TN for #NEET .this year also .

 

Already everybody was aware of the need for #NEET to be applicable for all states and TN is no exception – politicians in TN have been making a bogus claim that #NEET will put ”rural” students to great disadvantage and TN should be exempted permanently .

Initially TN requested and was exempted from #NEET for 2016 .

The then CM Jayalalitha wrote a letter thanking PM for exempting TN from #NEET for 2016 but requested permanent exemption citing ”Rural students and those from poorer socio-economic backgrounds will be unable to compete with urban elite students in such Common Entrance Examinations, which were designed to favor the urban elite”

http://indianexpress.com/article/education/ensure-neet-is-not-forced-on-tamil-nadu-even-in-future-jayalalithaa-to-pm-modi-2817957/

Already TN was given exemption in 2016 , now again passed 2 bills in assembly unanimously asking for exemption for #NEET sent it to centre .

http://www.hindustantimes.com/education/tamil-nadu-assembly-passes-neet-bills/story-a1r3EmQAoxW98hYujkIM2N.html

TN had enough time since May 2016 when the 1st exemption was given and what has been happening in TN is just ruling ADMK govt repeatedly saying they are pursuing with center and opposition parties blaming  it for inaction in getting exemption . The state had enough time to make the students prepare for #NEET but what they did was repeating that they will get exemption .

Repeatedly tn politicians keep parroting ” rural ” students will be losing out if #NEET comes . This is the pass % of plus two students in 2017 of all districts of TN –

+2 results 2017: District wise pass percentage

2017

Just a glance shows the most backward districts of TN – Ramanathapuram and Dindigul have a better pass % than Chennai ( Chennai city comprises of districts of Kanchipuram and Thiruvallur ) – so cumulatively Chennai city students have done poorly compared to the most backward districts .

So its a farce that the ”rural ” students will be put to disadvantage if #NEET is implemented in TN .

The real problem lies with the poor sub standard education system of TN.

There used to be a period when TN people used to top all india exams and that is the reason why now you will see many of them in senior positions of central government bureaucracy – what is the position now ? The numbers have fallen steeply  – the state board students fail miserably in almost all – all india exams – just 13 students out of 8 laks students of tn board entered IITM in 2016

http://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/in-other-news/030816/of-8-lakh-from-tamil-nadu-board-only-13-enter-iit-m.html 

If statistics are dug out it will be same story as far as performance of state board students in competitive exams – the main culprit are the successive dmk / admk governments who have ruined the quality of education in TN in the name of ” samacheer kalvi ” – These statistics should have ringed a warning bell if the governments were really sincere in tn board students faring well in all india exams – instead they chose to ignore their fault and invented reasons for exemption .

How many years a state can ask for exemption when already it is given in 2016 ?

There was some justification last year as students were not equipped but why exemption again this year ?

Giving exemption to TN for this year also for #NEET will be a injustice to CBSE students who find it next to impossible to get the kind of scores state board students get – it is a yearly joke that record number of students get 200/200 in all subjects – whereas they end up a big failure not only in just in all india exams but also clearing their subsequent engineering exams .

50% of Anna university engineering students fail in first year exams http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chennai/50-of-Anna-university-engineering-students-fail-in-first-year-exams/articleshow/56091449.cms

One among three engineering students in Tamil Nadu fails to graduate within 4 years http://www.newindianexpress.com/states/tamil-nadu/2016/aug/01/One-among-three-engineering-students-fails-to-graduate-within-4-years-in-Tamil-Nadu-1500018.html

Tamil Nadu continues to produce unemployable engineers http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chennai/Tamil-Nadu-continues-to-produce-unemployable-engineers/articleshow/50780273.cms

The above are a clear indicator that the quality of school education is very poor in TN – if record number of students get 200/200 in all subjects then why cant they perform after they join colleges and why are they unfit to good job placements ?

To me not a single politician is really bothered about welfare of students – haven’t come across any politician worry about quality of students instead they keep repeating a lie of rural students will be affected for the sake of a imaginary non existent vote bank .

On the brighter side TN education minister has taken few steps in recent months and also has made some promises that entire syllabus is being revamped to make the students competitive which should have been done much earlier .

Of total number of seats 85% of that goes to the state and balance 15% is filled up by all india quota .The state government tried a cover up of its failure by announcing 85% of the state quota  seats to state board students and 15% to CBSE students which is a mockery of #NEET and was luckily cancelled by Madras HC and now the case is in SC .

Now there are reports that TN is planning to ask for exemption to #NEET for 2017 and 2018 – at this rate there is no end to this .

The state board students cant be penalized for state government sleeping for a year but same time justice for CBSE students also has to be done .

One of the most viable solutions for TN government is to prepare 2 lists – 1st list based on #NEET and 2nd list as per their formula – whatever the excess number of seats comes TN govt should ask center to approve it as one time exemption and a substantial part of the excess seats can be adjusted by asking center to give up the 15% all india quota seats from TN . This will ensure that justice is done to both state board students as well as CBSE students .

Also center should strictly not allow future exemptions as states like West Bengal have now started to complain – there seems to be no merit in their claim and the opposition seems to be purely on political grounds .

If TN is given exemption for 2 years there is every possibility that opposition rules states ( non NDA states ) will start fresh demand and this will open a Pandora box .

There has to be a debate initiated on One Nation One Syllabus to prevent such scenarios in future as not only students but also their entire family is at tenterhooks till last minute .